Review: The Map of Us by Jules Preston


Genre: Fiction

Similar to: A Man Called Ove by Fredrik Backman

Could be enjoyed by: Quirky fiction lovers

Publication date: 4th May 2018

In keeping with my highly focused and organised lifestyle, I’ve FINALLY got round to reading and reviewing The Map of Us which I requested one whole year ago on Netgalley. Better late than never!

You see, the reason that I delayed…and delayed…and delayed reading the book was that I simply had no idea why I requested it. I think I got sucked in by all of the “next Eleanor Oliphant” hype but in reality it’s nothing like that.

The Map of Us is a complicated story of one family across the generations. There’s Violet, physically disabled and seemingly disowned by her family, growing up at a time when that kind of treatment was somewhat socially acceptable; Tilly, her granddaughter who likes statistics, analyses her relationships with quantitative data and creates a Compatibility Index to prove where her and her ex went wrong; her father who is a professional sand sculptor; her sister who is addicted to buying designer handbags she can’t afford and her brother who is leading world authority on the colour blue. There’s also a whole host of other odd people who crop up along the way, adding to the narrative of the numerous main characters. And – hahaha – they’re all super quirky too! Hahahaha…ha. Oh.

To me, it felt like the characters were all a bit, well, weird purely for the sake of it. Don’t get me wrong, I love an oddball but when literally everyone in the book has their own thing going on that is nothing whatsoever to do with the main narrative then it gets a bit tedious. It’s even harder when the novel is character driven and the plot is wafer thin. For example, Tilly’s Dad refuses to sculpt dolphins, even though they always win the competitions that he enters. Fine – that’s a nicely observed bit of humour but the point was repeated so many times it felt utterly laboured.

My other issue was with the structure of the book. The chapters are written from a first person perspective but it takes a while for you to work out who is actually speaking and that there’s more than one narrator. This stops being a problem once you’ve got to know the family a bit – the chapters are short so it doesn’t take too long – but it is quite hard to get into at first. I don’t know why you’d deliberately make it awkward for the reader?

Overall, I think my main issue was that I just couldn’t engage with the characters and as such, wasn’t really bothered about what happened to them. The book was described as being charming and quirky and I can see why but for me it needed more action and a stronger narrative thread. I didn’t hate the book – it was a nice enough read but unfortunately I got bored with it all.

Two and a half “Oh, do grow up”s out of five.

Cute and quirky but kinda dull. Not for me!



Please note that I read this book for free in exchange for an honest review courtesy of NetGalley. Thanks NetGalley!



8 thoughts on “Review: The Map of Us by Jules Preston

  1. I totally understand, I couldn’t connect with them either, they were too weird. I thought it would be a book like Eleanor Oliphant is Completely Fine too but it’s really not similar. I really enjoyed this honest review, and I’m kind of happy I’m not alone in feeling this way about the novel!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Your review made me think immediately of like a Wes Anderson movie and the “oddball quirky characters” sometimes just for the sake of being oddball and quirky. I have a hard time with those so I don’t think I’d like this one.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yes! I wouldn’t have minded if I’d known more about the characters instead of just their Odd Thing. I mean “my sister buys expensive designer handbags” tells me barely anything about her. I needed more substance.


  3. I do love a quirky weirdo, but here is something jarring about characters that are weird for the sake of it. There’s already enough strangeness in most people if a torch is shined onto their habits, and one of the reasons I love the comedy show Friday Night Dinner, with the family’s own idiolect, a shirtless, shouting-through-deafness dad, is that they are a bunch of weirdos but very realistic ones, just like my own family 😉

    Liked by 1 person

    1. It was like when a group of people introduce themselves on a team building away day with a “fun fact” – I knew nothing about any of the characters apart from their one weird Thing.

      Oh yes I love Friday Night Dinner! It was all the little subtleties that made it so funny – the way that Jim jumped every time he saw Wilson, their sons reverting to 14 year olds as soon as they entered the house, The Oiling of the Hinges Day…just like my family too! 😂


  4. I’ve seen so many books labelled “the next Eleanor Oliphant”- and half of my brain goes “yay I loved that book” and then the second half of my brain is like “wait, half the charm of that book was how unique it is, so how is this gonna measure up?” I know I’m definitely overthinking things, but this is why I’m not keen on the whole “the next” publishing phenomenon 😉 Shame all the characters felt weird just for the sake of it. It’s a pity it ended up being boring- but lol at your rating 😉


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s